Elder Joseph the Cave-Dweller Was Not True Orthodox

An online Synaxaristes including martyrologies and hagiographies of the lives of the Orthodox Church's saints. All Forum Rules apply. No polemics. No heated discussions. No name-calling.


User avatar
haralampopoulosjc
Member
Posts: 140
Joined: Tue 3 June 2025 9:22 pm
Faith: True Orthodox
Jurisdiction: GOC (Stephanos)
Location: Toronto
Contact:

Re: Elder Joseph the Cave-Dweller Was Not True Orthodox

Post by haralampopoulosjc »

Timeline of Elder Joseph's Synodia:

1921- Elder Joseph arrives on the Holy Mountain. At some point, he finds a spiritual companion in Elder Arsenios the Cave-Dweller.

1924- The New Calendar is introduced, and almost all of the monasteries on Mount Athos cease commemoration of the Patriarch. Elder Joseph and Elder Arsenios immediately join the zealots.

1936- Elder Ephraim of Katounakia is ordained a hieromonk by Bishop Germanos of the Cyclades

1937- A schism occurs among the GOC of Greece between the moderate zealots represented by Germanos of Demetrias and Chrysostom of Florina, and the stricter zealots led by Matthew of Bresthena and Germanos of the Cyclades. Elder Joseph and his synodia, as well as Elder Ephraim of Katounakia, align themselves with the Matthewites, participating in written denunciations of Germanos and Chrysostom.

1938- Elder Joseph's synodia moves from the Skete of Saint Basil to the Small Skete of Saint Anne.

1945- Elder Joseph's synodia leaves the Matthewites and submits to Metropolitan Chrysostom of Florina.

1947- Elder Joseph's synodia is joined by Elder Ephraim (future abbot of Iveron)

1950- Elder Joseph and his synodia leave the zealots and join the commemorators, probably as a reaction to the 1950 encyclical issued by Metropolitan Chrysostom of Florina, which declared the New Calendar State Church to be schismatic and graceless.

1951- In October, Elder Haralambos (future abbot of Dionysiou), is ordained a hieromonk by Bishop Hierotheos of Miletoupolis (1874–1956), a commemorating bishop who was living in a nearby hermitage.

1959- Elder Joseph reposes, Elder Arsenios the Cave-Dweller takes over the leadership of Elder Joseph's synodia.

1965- As a reaction to the "Lifting of the Anathemas", many of the monasteries on the Holy Mountain stopped commemorating the Patriarch. Elder Joseph's synodia does the same, and they remain zealots until at least 1972. Interestingly enough, during this time, Elder Ephraim (future abbot of Philotheou), would leave the Holy Mountain and serve in Old Calendarist parishes, in which he would commemorate Archbishop Auxentios during the liturgy. According to one account he even received a "laying on of hands" from Archbishop Auxentius for this purpose.

1972- Fr. George Viktovic, a former disciple of Elder Joseph, reposes. He was a Serb who had learned Greek out of love for his Elder. When the brothers of the synodia were fighting amongst themselves and going to the monasteries to become abbots, Fr. George was very sad. He went to the grave of the elder and kissed it, weeping, saying, “If you were still alive, they wouldn’t be doing this.” He also left, but he went the other way, to a cell outside the Russian monastery of St. Panteleimon and died there as a zealot. He had probably eaten some bad berries and died from that. He was only photographed once, at a funeral service at the Hilandar monastery, which is the only service in which a bishop is not commemorated.

Image

1973- Elder Ephraim becomes the abbot of Iveron Monastery

1975- After the repose of his elder Nikephoros (who was a zealot), Elder Ephraim of Katounakia joins the commemorators and forms his own brotherhood

1975- Elder Joseph the Cypriot becomes the spiritual father of the Monastery of Koutloumousiou

1983- Elder Arsenios the Cave-Dweller reposes at Dionysiou monastery, lying in a hospital bed next to Elder Gabriel of Dionysiou, the former abbot of the monastery, who dies around the same time. His nephew, Elder Haralambos, became the Abbot of Dionysiou in 1980.

User avatar
haralampopoulosjc
Member
Posts: 140
Joined: Tue 3 June 2025 9:22 pm
Faith: True Orthodox
Jurisdiction: GOC (Stephanos)
Location: Toronto
Contact:

Re: Elder Joseph the Cave-Dweller Was Not True Orthodox

Post by haralampopoulosjc »

At this point, I see three possible scenarios for the direction Elder Joseph's synodia took in the 1950s:

1) Elder Joseph and his synodia separated themselves from Metropolitan Chrysostom of Florina and all the other zealots in 1950 to avoid all the infighting among the Old Calendarists. They remained zealots but did not have communion with anyone outside of their synodia. However, this seems untenable given that Elder Haralambos did receive his ordination as a hieromonk from a commemorating bishop (Hierotheos of Miletoupolis).

2) Elder Joseph and his synodia sided with the monasteries and were in communion with the commemorators, but Elder Haralambos and Elder Ephraim did not commemorate the Patriarch during their liturgies. This wasn't as uncommon as one might think, at the time, especially before the Lifting of the Anathemas in 1964. Fr. Seraphim Rose talks about non-commemorators who are in communion with the commemorators in his article The Zealots of Mount Athos, Leaven of True Orthodoxy Today: "To be sure, the battle for Orthodoxy is intense also on the Holy Mountain, and unfortunately several monasteries are openly anti-Zealot, actually commemorating the apostate Patriarch of Constantinople, while others follow an unsteady and ultimately impossible path of compromise, rightfully having ceased to commemorate the Patriarch, but not yet breaking off communion with other monasteries which do commemorate him. Only one monastery — Esphigmenou — and that quite recently, has taken the pure Zealot stand of breaking off communion with the commemorators, and for the rest the Zealot movement is one of individuals, cells, and sketes on the Holy Mountain — some 300 monks in all, which, though far from a majority, is nonetheless a considerable proportion of the monks remaining on Mt. Athos." As you can see, Fr. Seraphim believed this to be an untenable position in the long term, and praised the monastery of Esphigmenou for taking the pure Zealot stand. To further back up this scenario, Elder Joseph didn't let any members of his synodia leave the Holy Mountain after this point, and he also forbade them from concelebrating with visiting New Calendar clerics, according to Bishop Klemes of Gardikion and Fr. Pantelimon Metropoulos. I think that this is the most likely scenario.

Scenario 3: Elder Joseph and his synodia started commemorating Patriarch Athenagoras in 1950 and did so until the synodia returned to the zealots in 1965. This is Elder Ephraim of Arizona's account of what happened, but I'm inclined to think that he embellished the details to justify his strange move from the EP to the ROCOR for six months in 1991, and then back to the EP, trying to create a parallel between his life and Elder Joseph's

Attachments
Elder Joseph on the Calendar Issue.pdf
(330.86 KiB) Downloaded 9 times
Elder Joseph the Cave-Dweller and the Calendar Issue (2).pdf
(3.49 MiB) Downloaded 7 times
Post Reply