Discord Spillover Was "The Place of Blessed Augustine in the Orthodox Church"

Feel free to tell our little section of the Internet why you're right. Forum rules apply.


Post Reply
User avatar
Suaidan
Protoposter
Posts: 1163
Joined: Thu 8 April 2004 2:31 pm
Faith: Orthodox
Jurisdiction: Autonomous Metropolia of the Americas
Location: Northeast PA

Re: Discord Spillover Was "The Place of Blessed Augustine in the Orthodox Church"

Post by Suaidan »

Icthys wrote: Tue 20 August 2024 12:38 pm

Esphigmenou broke communion with the GOC-K because one of their priests who visited had a credit card. They ascribe to every single "mark of the beast" rhetoric that has popped up in Greece. First it was the new IDs without religious affiliation, then it was barcodes, then it was the new SSN, then it was credit cards and now it's the electronic ID, every single time, without fail, they refer to those things as THE mark of the beast, which is simply not true. They might be precursors, yes, we need to ween off them, yes, but are these things the mark from revelations? No. Going so far as to refuse plastic bottle of water because they have barcodes on them. That's not an Esphigmenite position though, that's simply a very prevailing apocalypticism that's prevalent among the older generations of Greeks.

The barcodes do in fact contain 666 in binary in them. (https://www.av1611.org/666/barcode.html) The creator of the barcode system, George Laurer, literally admitted it, as does almost every source on the subject, with a large dose of "ha ha ha superstitious Christians" in it. You skipped the vaccine with your examples, by the way, which if I remember correctly, divided the GOC-Kallinikos Synod, and was extremely controversial.

The monks of Esphigmenou (who aren't headless, they have an abbot, but since you understand nothing about monasteries and live on Discord don't seem to care about that) have a better understanding of the signs of Antichrist than I first understood. 20 years ago, I thought their view of the barcodes, the cashless society, full government surveillance through purchase tracking, RFID, and surveillance through the national ID system were a bit off the deep end. (For the record, it wasn't just Esphigmenou; True Orthodox Russians and Greeks were concerned as well.)

Now I try to take barcodes off things before they're in the altar. I have a RFID-blocking wallet to avoid tracking. CBDC programs being implemented globally are real. And we all lived through COVID. (I'm not even talking about cell phone tracking today).

Anyone who thinks the monks were wrong at this point doesn't just misunderstand Orthodox eschatology; they're clueless consoomers. (Y'all know what I mean by the spelling.)

Fr Joseph Suaidan (Suaiden, same guy)

User avatar
Suaidan
Protoposter
Posts: 1163
Joined: Thu 8 April 2004 2:31 pm
Faith: Orthodox
Jurisdiction: Autonomous Metropolia of the Americas
Location: Northeast PA

Re: Discord Spillover Was "The Place of Blessed Augustine in the Orthodox Church"

Post by Suaidan »

Icthys wrote: Tue 20 August 2024 1:06 pm

Oh and btw one of the so-called anti-Augustinians that Unseen is talking about was literally baptized as Augustine after the St. Augustine of Hippo.
So strike one.

So what? That's good. Instead of being ashamed for past abuses of the Saint on your part, you are acting like that anti-Augustinianism did not exist. That's a lie. Instead of saying (as did Metr Demetrius, by the way) that "mistakes were made", you're just trying to silence a guy.

Icthys wrote: Tue 20 August 2024 1:06 pm

Unseen broke the rules of the server, that's why he was banned, wherein he would misrepresent points people made and argue for hours against the points that didn't even belong to the people he was arguing against. When that would fail he would go to DMs just to profane others (really masculine behavior there, dude).
So strike two.

Nobody cares about your server here. This is not a forum owned by blue-haired liberals (which is what Discord literally is.) This is a place where we can speak freely, and if people disagree with you, you just have to deal with it. Break our rules, you'll be in trouble. But if you want to go CCCP-style and pretend to police us HERE, well, you're gonna find out what free people are made of.

Icthys wrote: Tue 20 August 2024 1:06 pm

Instead of letting these topics die and just focus on his own spiritual journey, we have this thread that's spiralled out of control.
Strike three.

I purposely split this thread so people could speak freely. If you want to enforce your Discord server rules here, well, ya know where to go.

Icthys wrote: Tue 20 August 2024 1:06 pm

He bases his idea on HTM on Met. Demetrius' as if it's gospel, but in the same breath he'll pretend tollhouses are theologoumenos logos. Please ask Demetrius, a former Bostonite monk himself, what he thinks of tollhouses.
Strike four.

Why did you remove his title? In any case, no one doubts the toll-houses here. Yes, we know HTM did and we know the whole battle with Fr Seraphim. Stop trying to resurrect long-dead battles. They're only alive in people's imaginations.

Icthys wrote: Tue 20 August 2024 1:06 pm

Unseen has isolated himself because of the super correctness that Fr. Seraphim talked about.
Strike five.

Dude, it's a Discord server, not the Church of Christ.

Icthys wrote: Tue 20 August 2024 1:06 pm

And for all his talk of proper Orthodoxy, he's not even baptized. Not even part of the kingdom of God, no prayers of exorcism done on him and no communion was ever received. Talking the talk but never having walked the walk, so to speak. Is his aggression born out of zeal or out of outside influence? Considering the profanities thrown against members of the chat, I'd say the latter.
My two cents, get baptized, leave the internet for a while and come back with a more sober mentality, one less influenced by demonic presence, which is a reality in all unbaptized and even baptized individuals.
Genuinely not trying to pull a holier-than-thou, but you're only falling into deeper wroth through the nonstop arguing, rather than being virtuous.

You're literally pulling a holier-than-thou while genuinely pretending you aren't.

Fr Joseph Suaidan (Suaiden, same guy)

User avatar
Suaidan
Protoposter
Posts: 1163
Joined: Thu 8 April 2004 2:31 pm
Faith: Orthodox
Jurisdiction: Autonomous Metropolia of the Americas
Location: Northeast PA

Re: Discord Spillover Was "The Place of Blessed Augustine in the Orthodox Church"

Post by Suaidan »

Icthys wrote: Tue 20 August 2024 2:37 pm

Esphigmenou is headless, that's a fact, it's not demonic to state facts, in fact it's demonic to dismiss facts, because demons lie.
Also, you're unbaptized, that is also fact, it's not a weapon against a debate because this is not even a debate, this is the spiraling of an argument that you misrepresented.
Take both Fr. Seraphim's quote into account when you're arguing about tollhouses and the Matthew quote when you're accusing others of being effeminate and heretical.
Absolutely nobody said in the discord that Esphigmenou deserved the raids....

Cutting off here. Saying "they brought this upon themselves by isolating themselves" is exactly what was said above and got me involved. So you might want to check your "demons" in the thread, anon.

Fr Joseph Suaidan (Suaiden, same guy)

User avatar
Suaidan
Protoposter
Posts: 1163
Joined: Thu 8 April 2004 2:31 pm
Faith: Orthodox
Jurisdiction: Autonomous Metropolia of the Americas
Location: Northeast PA

Re: Discord Spillover Was "The Place of Blessed Augustine in the Orthodox Church"

Post by Suaidan »

waiting for the "what is a Discord server" comment lol

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discord

And here's their founder lololol

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jason_Citron

Fr Joseph Suaidan (Suaiden, same guy)

User avatar
Bruder Klaus
Newbie
Posts: 37
Joined: Sun 14 January 2024 2:13 pm
Faith: True Orthodox
Jurisdiction: GOC-M
Location: Germany

Re: Discord Spillover Was "The Place of Blessed Augustine in the Orthodox Church"

Post by Bruder Klaus »

Suaidan wrote: Tue 20 August 2024 3:25 pm
RocaRemnant wrote: Tue 20 August 2024 7:41 am
Rumpelstiltskin wrote: Mon 19 August 2024 9:24 pm

It’s the unfortunate reality they’ve put themselves in.

I don't think it's fair to hold monasteries, especially on Mount Athos, to the same standard as laymen when it comes to joining a TO synod. As far as I understand, Mount Athos has always been decentralized in nature, historically. So forcing them to 'pick a side' (as in TO synods) as long as they are faithful to true Orthodoxy, that seems to be the important thing. It could be possible they are opting to wait until the GOC can heal it's own schisms and get itself together or something like that. I have no doubt they know what they are doing regardless, in these confusing times. Just my $0.02

I understand but some people here feel Esphigmenou is exempt from criticism (very sad)

I think legitimate criticism from Athonite monastics makes sense. Not noobies on a Discord server. People doing that should be ashamed of themselves.

That's straight up pathetic. This is one of the reasons why I blew up the server. Now we're seeing the results.

Whatever that has to do with Discord. As you can see, it doesn't matter if we debate on Discord or the forum. Your decision to delete the server is a different subject. If you want to start a discussion on that, you can have it. I rather wouldn't do that, if I were you.

User avatar
Bruder Klaus
Newbie
Posts: 37
Joined: Sun 14 January 2024 2:13 pm
Faith: True Orthodox
Jurisdiction: GOC-M
Location: Germany

Re: Discord Spillover Was "The Place of Blessed Augustine in the Orthodox Church"

Post by Bruder Klaus »

Now please delete this thread. You were able to do so with the Discord, so you can do it.

Icthys
Newbie
Posts: 4
Joined: Sun 30 June 2024 9:37 pm

Re: Discord Spillover Was "The Place of Blessed Augustine in the Orthodox Church"

Post by Icthys »

"Let nothing be done without the bishop. See that you all follow the bishop, even as Jesus Christ does the Father, and the presbytery as you would the apostles; and reverence the deacons, as being the institution of God. Let no man do anything connected with the Church without the bishop." - Epistle to the Smyrnaeans (St. Ignatius)

I'm not trying to enforce any discord server rules because frankly I don't care about discord.
There's a misrepresentation of the points made by us that is being misunderstood on the other side. Nobody, and I repeat, NOBODY said Esphigmenou deserves death and cops barging on their monasteries and having a bunch of Bart worshippers taking over. When it was said "brought this upon themselves" the isolation, the isolation from the rest of the TO world was brought upon themselves. On the matters of authority on "being Greek" it's not about being Greek, it's about speaking the language, when Methodios speaks, it's about living in the area where he resides for decades, meaning I can understand his culture, meaning that I can talk to people who have met him in person meaning I can understand him a bit better than Anglophones separated by an entire Atlantic ocean between them, they don't even have captions on their videos, you can't listen to Methodios without speaking Greek, if that's some kind of mistake on my part, feel free to think that.

Their struggle against Ecumenism is a blessed one, but they've made mistakes that made everyone else distance themselves from them. Which happens, it's a thing humans do, mistakes. Their stance against barcodes is an extremely strict one, they don't remove barcodes, they won't touch anything having barcodes, which includes the things you've removed the barcodes from, Father. To them, you've filled your altar with demonic artifacts. It's not a case of being wary of surveillance, nobody thinks that CBDCs aren't a problem or that tracking doesn't exist.

My point regarding being anti-Augustine pertained to the people in the server, not the Greek TOs in general.

An abbot is not a bishop, Esphigmenou is still the only non-commemorating monastic body in Athos without a bishop, and yes, that does mean they're headless, because they're a clerical and monastic collective without an episcopacy overseeing them. Doesn't mean they're not Orthodox, but it does mean they have no bishop, ergo, headless.

My salvation and Unseen's salvation are our own personal struggles and we're free to see to them as much as we want. The only reason I popped in the thread, was because both Byzantophile and Rocaremnant were being misrepresented and the fact that they're unable to have their own opinions and scrutinize errors because they're not Athonite monastics, is fallacious, an appeal to authority. You don't have to be a priest to criticize, were we supposed to silence ourselves when the Chrysostomos of Attica gave away relics?
To add to it, these criticisms do not belong only to a bunch of "blue haired discord communists" but to a lot of clergy and monastics within TO, that's why the other synods won't make a statement in outright support of Esphigmenou.

Unseen still thinks "they brought this upon themselves" means that Esphigmenou deserves to get torched to the ground, which is what: "You’ve admitted it yourself. It came out your own mouths that they were at fault for their current persecution and you repeatedly call them headless." implies. We. Never. Said. That. It's an impossibility on his part to think that maybe he misunderstood what we meant, even though in this thread, we repeatedly said what we meant. But apparently clarifying our point is not good enough, the point we made is the point Unseen thinks we made, we don't have our own voices, only what Unseen thinks we said. I will not allow either myself, or Rocaremnant, or Byzantophile to get slandered to third parties for absolute fabrications. Nobody and I repeat NOBODY said ESPHIGMENOU DESERVES TO GET PERSECUTED AND THAT THEY'RE NOT ORTHODOX, nobody, and by nobody I mean no-one, and by no-one I mean nobody. That's a strawman. End of story.

Getting baptized is a good thing, and the sooner you can get to it (properly, with a proper catechism, try not to misrepresent this point either) the better. St. Constantine got baptized at the end of his life, glory to God, but there's a reason we have infant baptisms, and it's not just infant mortality. It's about being able to partake in the mysteries of the Church as much as possible while you're alive.

And finally, as much as Unseen wants to portray it as such, it's not a debate. He's arguing that we said B when we said A and he's attacking us for saying B. It's a strawman, I don't have to refer to it as a debate. Especially when we're being referred to as effeminate heretics because we don't exactly belong in his own super-correct cognition of what True Orthodoxy is about.

Post Reply