Recommended commentaries on Old Testament?

Reading from the Old Testament, Holy Gospels, Acts, Epistles and Revelation, our priests' and bishops' sermons, and commentary by the Church Fathers. All Forum Rules apply.


Post Reply
User avatar
Matthew Fisher
Newbie
Posts: 6
Joined: Mon 1 July 2024 1:06 pm
Faith: Orthodox Christian
Jurisdiction: American Eparchy, GOC-K
Location: Maine, USA

Recommended commentaries on Old Testament?

Post by Matthew Fisher »

I recently watched an excellent talk by Bishop Maximus of Pelagonia (GOC-K) called "Acquiring a Patristic Mindset". One of the topics he addressed at length was Patristic commentary on the Scriptures and the difference between the Antiochian (more literal) and Alexandrian (more allegorical) schools of interpretation. I found it fascinating. Video link:

Are there any Orthodox commentaries on the Old Testament that you'd recommend? I'm particularly interested in allegorical commentaries.

In the short term I'd especially like to read allegorical commentaries concerning Righteous Phineas son of Eleazar, who appears in Numbers 25, Judges 20, and Psalm 105 (LXX)/106. What I've found so far is that St Gregory of Nyssa mentions St Phineas in "On the Baptism of Christ", stating that it is the "javelin of baptism" that slays the old man.

Righteous Phineas is a lightning rod for modernist holier-than-Orthodox-Tradition commentary. One person who's "wrong on the internet" described Phineas as "the patron saint of hate crime". The assumption is that if we call Old Testament saints like Phineas righteous then we would also consider ourselves justified under the New Covenant in going about as vigilantes, slaying whomever we choose. (Rolls eyes)

As dumb as such an unfavorable attitude toward the Scriptures might be, I see clearly that I too am quite ignorant of the allegorical interpretation of the Old Testament. Would like to address that need. Phineas is my baptismal name -- not because I'm like him in any respect yet. But I do aspire to become more zealous according to knowledge.

Thomas_Deretich
Newbie
Posts: 31
Joined: Fri 14 September 2012 10:23 pm

Re: Recommended commentaries on Old Testament?

Post by Thomas_Deretich »

The Ancient Christian Commentary on Scripture series is a useful place to start

User avatar
Stylite Nous
Jr Member
Posts: 68
Joined: Tue 27 August 2019 10:12 am

Re: Recommended commentaries on Old Testament?

Post by Stylite Nous »

Thomas_Deretich wrote: Tue 29 October 2024 11:16 pm

The Ancient Christian Commentary on Scripture series is a useful place to start

it does have some unfortunate inclusions, though, like Theodore of Mopsuestia IIRC

a sinner, but not a heretic

(I am 'ascender' on YouTube superchats)

User avatar
Theodore813
Newbie
Posts: 30
Joined: Mon 1 January 2024 9:05 pm
Jurisdiction: ROAC
Location: Louisiana
Contact:

Re: Recommended commentaries on Old Testament?

Post by Theodore813 »

Matthew Fisher wrote: Sat 27 July 2024 4:31 pm

I recently watched an excellent talk by Bishop Maximus of Pelagonia (GOC-K) called "Acquiring a Patristic Mindset". One of the topics he addressed at length was Patristic commentary on the Scriptures and the difference between the Antiochian (more literal) and Alexandrian (more allegorical) schools of interpretation. I found it fascinating. Video link:

Are there any Orthodox commentaries on the Old Testament that you'd recommend? I'm particularly interested in allegorical commentaries.

In the short term I'd especially like to read allegorical commentaries concerning Righteous Phineas son of Eleazar, who appears in Numbers 25, Judges 20, and Psalm 105 (LXX)/106. What I've found so far is that St Gregory of Nyssa mentions St Phineas in "On the Baptism of Christ", stating that it is the "javelin of baptism" that slays the old man.

Righteous Phineas is a lightning rod for modernist holier-than-Orthodox-Tradition commentary. One person who's "wrong on the internet" described Phineas as "the patron saint of hate crime". The assumption is that if we call Old Testament saints like Phineas righteous then we would also consider ourselves justified under the New Covenant in going about as vigilantes, slaying whomever we choose. (Rolls eyes)

As dumb as such an unfavorable attitude toward the Scriptures might be, I see clearly that I too am quite ignorant of the allegorical interpretation of the Old Testament. Would like to address that need. Phineas is my baptismal name -- not because I'm like him in any respect yet. But I do aspire to become more zealous according to knowledge.

Great post! I love the Holy Scriptures. I come from a reformed Protestant background so I pray God continues to fuel the spark in me to continually read the Scriptures. There are so many layers of understanding. The Scriptures are truly a treasure.

“We’re holding onto our Orthodoxy by our fingernails.”

Post Reply