A(n excruciatingly) fuller account of my journey from non-denominational evangelical Stone-Campbell/Restoration Movement background to Anglicanism (ECUSA) to inquiry into Orthodoxy can be found here:
http://www.geocities.com/chealy5/PEIntroduction.htm
Here's the gist.
I ran into some contradictions in my heritage church beliefs. How could we have a sacramental understanding of baptism but a Zwinglian understanding of the Lord's Supper? How could we be a unity and reform movement but essentially ignore some 1700 years of Church history?
I then discovered liturgy and the daily office. Being Romophobic (okay, a bit of an exagerration ), and being a huge admirer of T. S. Eliot (and C. S. Lewis), it was perhaps natural that I look into Anglicanism. Doing so opened me up a bit to Rome, but I never could get over papal infallibility and the immaculate conception. I was confirmed in ECUSA in April 1996.
After a little more than three years, I began to see that my Anglo-Catholic parish and diocese were islands in a troubled sea, and not the reality of what ECUSA was. Going to seminary, to discern a vocation to the Anglican priesthood, only confirmed that . . . in spades!
After only one term/semester (I started mid-year) at seminary I almost didn't go back. But I didn't want to appear a failure, I didn't want to uproot my family again, and I sincerely thought I could be a change agent.
After that term, it was summer, and through several serendipitous occurrences, I started investigating Orthodoxy. I have been doing so now for the last three years, with increasing seriousness and devotion. LIke anastasios, I have a spouse who right now appears to want nothing to do with Orthodoxy, so it is at times challenging. (But things have gotten better in the last few months, and it's possible she is reaching a new state of openness.)
I'm wrestling right now, with a new baby (our first) soon to arrive (7 Aug.--or whenever the baby wants). I want to become a catechumen. But with 1 Peter 3:7, I'm trying not to rock my wife's world any more than it currently is.
Pray for me, a sinner.